Why have
the last four years had mega-firestorms in California? Certainly we are
experiencing increasingly toxic climate change, from extended droughts to
record heat waves. And these climate changes have created conditions
that create fires and the fires have become catastrophic.
But, why
else? The science to keep this from happening has been known and
advocate for decades. The problem is a culture in the state and in the
state government that won't follow the science. Scientists have warned that the
California management of the forests has long created conditions that would
eventually lead to catastrophe, and the catastrophe has arrived. Elizabeth Weil
of ProPublica has an excellent article that explores this (“They Know How to Prevent Megafires. Why Won’t Anybody
Listen?”).
Around
1905 the State of California adopted a "War-on-Fire" approach to
California fires. From her article:
“The
overarching reason is culture. In 1905, the U.S. Forest Service was created
with a military mindset…The war-on-fire mentality found especially fertile
ground in California, a state that had emerged from the genocide and cultural
destruction of tribes who understood fire and relied on its benefits to tend
their land. That state then repopulated itself in the Gold Rush with extraction
enthusiasts, and a little more than half a century later, it suffered a truly
devastating fire. Three-thousand people died, and hundreds of thousands were
left homeless, after the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and attendant fires. The
overwhelming majority of the destruction came from the flames, not the quake.
Small wonder California’s fire ethos has much more in common with a field
surgeon wielding a bone saw than a preventive medicine specialist with a tray
full of vaccines.
How do
you wage war on fire? What that means is that if there is a fire, CalFire
goes and puts it out. That sounds like a good approach, right? I always
thought so. But, woe is us, it has terrible consequences.
The
science says that we need to let fuel burn. If we don't, the
fuel builds up and builds up and builds up. And then Climate Change
enters the picture and we get record heat and winds and a spark from
lightening or a campfire or some stupid fireworks display sets off a fire that
turns into a conflagration that ends up creating its own weather and roars to unprecedented
extremes.
From her
article:
"A seventy-word primer: We dug ourselves
into a deep, dangerous fuel imbalance due to one simple fact. We live in a
Mediterranean climate that’s designed to burn, and we’ve prevented it from
burning anywhere close to enough for well over a hundred years. Now climate
change has made it hotter and drier than ever before, and the fire we’ve been
forestalling is going to happen, fast, whether we plan for it or
not."
So,
forest mismanagement has been going on for 100 years, and climate change just
keeps getting worse. How much excess fuel needs to burn? 20 million
acres. How much are we burning? About 40,000
acres per year. The rest will burn
itself. Nature will do what our War of
Fire won’t do.
What
other factors are at cause? Money.
It turns
out that CalFire is a giant financial enterprise that gets paid to wage war on
fires, to put out fires. And it turns out that doing controlled burns is
a financial and career risk for "burn bosses" because if they do a
controlled burn and it gets out of hand their career suffers. And,
environmental laws have strict limits on air quality that prevent some
controlled burns because of other air quality issues at the time of the
scheduled burn. So it just becomes a bureaucratic obstacle course to do
controlled burns. So, not there is actually a financial incentive to have a War
on Fire. By the way, apparently in the
Southeast U.S. a stronger policy of controlled burns are practiced and
accepted.
The
governor and the U.S. Forest Service agreed to allow more controlled
burns. Nice, except it is woefully
inadequate. We need to burn a million acres
a year, and we’re increasing from about 20,000 to 40,000. Whoopee.
The
firefighters are stretched too thin and are wearing out. And we haven’t even entered the traditional
fire season of October November. From
the article:
“As Ingalsbee said, “You won’t find any
climate deniers on the fire line.”
We need
change. Fires are indigenous to
California and the dry west. We need to
stop the War-on-Fire and learn to live in balance with fire. We need to learn to live with fire, manage
fire, control fire, live in dominion with fire not try to dominate fire – fire will
win that war.
We need
to do both - properly manage the forests in California and stop and reverse
climate change nationally and internationally. The world is becoming
uninhabitable. It is all different now.